Easter at Plain & Fancy Farm

All-you-can-eat family-style dining for Easter.

Join us this Easter Sunday April 20, 2025 for a scrumptious family-style Easter themed meal.  Enjoy a tasty all-you-can-eat meal served family-style that includes Lancaster County favorites and traditional Easter items. All Inclusive Pricing! 

Reservations open 2/1 at 10AM. CALL (717) 768-4400 to make your reservation.

All-Inclusive Price

$44 per adult| $22 per child (ages 4-12)

Includes non-alcoholic beverage, tax and gratuity

Main Entrees: Fried Chicken, Ham with Apple Cider Sauce, and Roast Beef with Au Jus

Sides: Mashed Potatoes with Gravy, Browned Buttered Noodles, Green Beans, Candied Sweet Potatoes, Glazed Carrots, Rolls with Butter, and Cole Slaw

Desserts: Cheesecake and Carrot Cake

Easter Family-Style Meal Pricing at Smokehouse BBQ & Brews
Easter Family-Style Meal Pricing at Smokehouse BBQ & Brews

Looking for an Easy at Home Easter Meal? Try our Easter To-Go!

It is a meal for 4 for just $95 including tax.

Meal includes:

Easter To-Go Menu

  • 3 Pounds of Oven Roasted Ham
  • 1 Quart of Brown Buttered Noodles
  • 1 Quart of Mashed Potatoes, plus gravy.
  • 1 Quart of Candied Sweet Potatoes
  • 1 Quart of Green Beans
  • 8 Dinner Rolls
  • Coleslaw
  • 4 Slices of Cheesecake

No substitutions. Call (717) 419-1337 to place your order for Easter To-Go.

Commonly Asked Questions:

  • How long do I have to enjoy my meal on Easter?
    • Each table will have a maximum of 1.5 hours to dine due to the all-you-can-eat family-style service and Easter demand.
  • Will I have to share my table with other families or groups?
    • No, unlike traditional family-style dining in Lancaster County, you will only be seated at a table with your group.
  • What is the minimum number of guests per reservation?
    • As this is family-style, it is a 2 person minimum per table with a 12 person maximum per table. If you are more than 12, you can have additional reservations but we can’t guarantee your tables will be close together and we will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.
  • Can I order off the menu instead of doing the family-style meal?
    • No, only family-style will be available on Easter day.
  • What are the gluten-free options?
    • Green beans, ham, roast beef, Cole slaw and candied sweet potatoes. The mashed potatoes are also gluten-free, but the gravy is not. Sorry, there will be no substitutions or special requests.
  • Are alcoholic drinks an additional charge?
    • Yes, any alcoholic drinks purchased will be in addition to the set price of the meal.
  • Can I take any leftovers of my family-style meal home with me?
    • No, unfortunately no to-go boxes will be available for the Easter family-style offering as it is all-you-can-eat.
  • Does the price of the meal include gratuity?
    • Yes, the price of the meal includes gratuity as well as the meal, non-alcoholic beverage, and tax.
  • Can I make an Easter reservation online?
    • No, reservations can only be made by calling (717) 768-4400.
  • Do I need to make a reservation?
    • Reservations are highly encouraged for Easter, as seating is limited. We can’t not guarantee space will be available on Easter for walk-ins.
  • What is the cancellation policy?
    • We appreciate at least 72 hour notification.
  • Will your regular menu be available on Easter?
    • No, we will only be serving our Easter menu.
  • What is the max party size?
    • Our maximum reservation size is 12 people for Easter. If you make multiple reservations, we can’t guarantee that you will be seated close to each other or in the same dining room. We will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.
  • If my group is larger than 20 for Easter, can I call the group sales number?
    • For Easter, our max reservation size is 12 people. However, you can have multiple reservations. We just can’t guarantee that you will be seated close to each other or in the same dining room. We will not be able to move tables in order for groups larger than 12 to sit together.
  • For the Easter To-Go, can I make changes?
    • No, we will not take substitution
  • What is Gluten-Free in the Easter To-G0?
    • Green beans, ham, roast beef, Cole slaw and candied sweet potatoes. The mashed potatoes are also gluten-free, but the gravy is not.
  • When do I need to order Easter To-Go by?
    • Orders for our To-Go must be placed by 4/13/25.
  • For the Easter To-Go, I only have 5 people, can I order 1.25 Easter To-Gos?
    • No, you need to order a full Easter To-Go. You can order multiple Easter To-Go Packages if you choose.